Litter Box Types Compared: Covered, Open, Top-Entry, Sifting
Open boxes suit most cats, covered and top-entry boxes trade privacy for odor and access limits. Compare all four types, plus sifting boxes and sizing.

For most healthy adult cats, a large open litter box is the easiest type to use and keep clean. Covered boxes give people less visible mess and cats more privacy, but they hold odor inside and some cats avoid them. Top-entry boxes keep litter from being kicked out, and sifting boxes save scooping time. Each type fits some cats and homes better than others.
What is the best litter box type for most cats?
An open box with low sides, or one side lower for entry, suits most cats. The cat can see around it, step in and out freely and turn around without bumping into walls. Open boxes are also the simplest to scoop and wash because nothing blocks access.
The drawbacks are practical. Litter gets kicked or tracked outside, and the smell is not contained. A cat that digs hard may still scatter litter over the edge, which is where high-sided open boxes help.
Are covered litter boxes a good idea?
A covered box hides waste and keeps most of the scattering inside, which many owners prefer. Some cats like the privacy, especially in busy homes.
The hood also traps odor and ammonia in a small space. A cat may find the box unpleasant, and owners may notice less because the smell is hidden. A covered box needs scooping as often as an open one.
Other problems to watch for:
- A cat that feels cornered, since the entrance is the only way out.
- Older or arthritic cats that struggle with a raised lip or flap door.
- Tall hoods that make it hard to see how dirty the box is.
If a cat starts going outside the box after you add a hood, remove the hood first. Our guide to why cats pee outside the litter box covers the medical and box-related causes, and a veterinarian should check any sudden change in habits.
Who should use a top-entry litter box?
A top-entry box has a lid with an opening, so the cat jumps in from above. Litter stays inside because the cat steps on the lid when leaving, which helps clean off paws. It also suits homes with dogs, since a dog cannot easily reach the contents.
It is a poor choice for kittens, seniors, cats with joint pain, overweight cats or those recovering from surgery, because jumping in and climbing out takes effort. Large cats may find the opening too tight. For recovery periods, see the guide on box setup after surgery.
How do sifting litter boxes work?
A sifting box has stacked trays. Clumps stay on an upper tray with slots or holes, and you lift it to let clean litter fall through to the tray beneath. You then discard the clumps without a scoop.
They can save time, but they work best with the clumping or granule sizes the maker recommends. Soft clumps can crumble and fall through, and sticky ones can jam the slots. Used with the wrong litter, they can be harder to clean than a standard box. Check which litters suit your box in our comparison of clay, clumping, silica and plant-based litters.
How big should a litter box be?
A common guideline is a box about one and a half times the length of the cat, measured from nose to the base of the tail. Many store-bought boxes are smaller than that, so a large storage tub with a cut-down entry is a popular alternative. Litter depth of roughly 2 to 3 inches (5 to 8 cm) is standard for most clumping litters.
Keep boxes in quiet, easy-to-reach spots, away from food and water bowls. The usual rule is one box per cat plus one extra, explained in how many litter boxes per cat.
How do you choose between the types?
- Single healthy adult cat: open box, large size.
- Cat that kicks litter: a high-sided open box or top-entry box.
- Shy cat: a covered box can work, but watch for avoidance.
- Senior cat or one with joint pain: low entry, open box.
- Owner who wants less scooping: a sifting box with the right litter.
Most cats do best when the type stays the same. If you change boxes, put the new one beside the old one for a while and let the cat choose. Mechanical alternatives are covered in our guide to choosing an automatic litter box.
The ASPCA publishes general advice on litter box problems, and your veterinarian can rule out health causes when a cat avoids its box. The American Veterinary Medical Association also offers pet owner resources.
Quick answers
Do cats prefer covered or uncovered boxes?
Cats vary, but many accept an uncovered box more readily. If you are unsure, offer one of each and see which gets used.
How often should a litter box be scooped?
Scoop at least once a day, and remove all litter and wash the box with mild soap and water on a regular schedule. Do not mix cleaning chemicals, and avoid strong scents.
Can a dog get into a top-entry box?
Small dogs may manage it, but the lid makes access harder than with an open box. A box in a room the dog cannot enter is more reliable.



