Only 18.3% of Pet Owners Rank Sustainability in Buying, Survey Says

A Kansas State survey of 2,038 pet owners and 409 vets found sustainability matters to both, but cost and safety drive pet food purchases.

Cute Pomeranian dog next to a food bowl on a wooden floor, looking up indoors.
Photo: Cup of Couple / Pexels

Pet owners and veterinarians say sustainability matters, yet few put it first when they buy. In a Kansas State University (KSU) survey, only 18.3% of owners picked sustainability among their important purchase attributes, well behind cost at 61.6% and safety at 51.2%, according to Pet Food Processing.

Lonnie Hobbs Jr., Ph.D., of KSU’s Department of Agricultural Economics, presented the findings at Pet Food Collab 2026 at the university last month. The national online survey collected responses from 2,038 U.S. pet owners and 409 veterinarians.

Who answered the survey

Of the owners, 38% lived in dog-only households, 27% in cat-only households and 35% had both pets. Some 81% said they view their pet “like a child or family.” Millennials were the largest generational group at 33%. Sixty-six percent said dry kibble is their pet’s main food, and 19% said wet food.

The veterinarians averaged 21.5 years of experience, and 96% work mostly with companion animals.

What sustainability means to each group

Both groups tied sustainability mostly to the environment. When asked whether they link it most with environmental, economic or social factors, 46% of owners and 67.7% of veterinarians chose environmental. Economic was the pick of 29.3% of owners and 23.7% of veterinarians, and social was chosen by 24.7% of owners and 8.6% of veterinarians.

Among specific features, ingredient sourcing came first for both: 30% of owners and 33.3% of veterinarians. “Environmentally friendly” followed, chosen by 30.8% of veterinarians and 24.3% of owners.

Importance versus action

Owners rated sustainability at an average of 6.99 out of 10, and veterinarians at 6.29. Hobbs stressed that saying it matters does not mean people act on it.

Purchase rankings show the gap. Behind cost and safety came natural or organic labeling (31.6%), brand recommendation (30.7%) and ease of use (28.5%). Sustainability, at 18.3%, ranked lower.

The reasons owners gave for choosing their current pet food point the same way: 37.7% said nutrition or health, 32.3% said price or affordability and 28.9% said brand trust. Only 6.9% named ethical or environmental reasons.

How veterinarians choose and recommend food

Asked what they weigh when evaluating a pet food, 72.9% of veterinarians said scientific evidence, 55% said palatability, 42.8% said efficacy and 40.8% said health benefits or claims.

Health benefits also seem to drive their recommendations of sustainable food. Some 57.7% said they would recommend a sustainable food if it benefited the pet, and 52.6% said they would if it benefited the environment.

Why it matters

For pet food companies, the survey suggests a sustainability claim on the label rarely closes a sale. Hobbs offered four recommendations to narrow the gap between stated values and buying:

  • Connect sustainability to the pet by describing sourcing, ingredients and packaging in terms of pet health, safety and quality.
  • Name the specific practice, such as responsibly sourced protein, instead of using the label “sustainable” alone.
  • Give veterinarians evidence of pet benefits they can use in the exam room.
  • Pair sustainability with a trusted value proposition, since it rarely carries a product alone.

What comes next

Hobbs said deeper analyses are on the way. Peer-reviewed papers are forthcoming on what shapes sustainability importance for pet owners, what drives veterinarians’ recommendations of sustainable food, and how owners’ and veterinarians’ perceptions compare directly.

Source: Pet Food Processing