Mandatory Pet Food Recalls: How the FDA’s Recall Power Works

The FDA can order a mandatory pet food recall when a company will not act voluntarily. How the power works, who signs the order and what owners do.

A detailed macro shot of scattered dog food pellets.
Photo: German Suarez / Pexels

The Food and Drug Administration can order a company to stop distributing a pet food and recall it. Congress gave the agency that power in the Food Safety Modernization Act, signed on Jan. 4, 2011. The FDA has to offer the company a chance to recall the food on its own first, which is why most pet food recalls owners see are still described as voluntary.

What is a mandatory pet food recall?

A mandatory recall is one the government orders after a company declines to pull a product itself. The rule sits in federal law as 21 U.S. Code § 350l, published by Cornell’s Legal Information Institute, under the heading “Mandatory recall authority.” The text speaks of the Secretary, meaning the Secretary of Health and Human Services, and the FDA is the agency inside that department that handles food.

The section covers any “article of food” other than infant formula, and it names harm to “humans or animals” as the trigger. Federal food law treats animal feed and pet food as food, so kibble, canned food, raw diets and treats all fall under it.

When can the FDA use this power?

The FDA can act when it finds a reasonable probability of two things at once. The food has to be adulterated under section 342 of the same title, or misbranded under section 343(w), the provision on allergen labeling. Using the food or being exposed to it also has to be likely to cause serious adverse health consequences or death to people or animals.

Exposure counts as well as eating. An owner who scoops contaminated food and a pet that eats it are both covered by that wording.

The agency may base its finding on the reportable food registry, a system through which companies report dangerous products, or on information from any other source.

How does a mandatory recall unfold?

The law sets out a sequence, and the company gets more than one chance to respond.

  1. The FDA gives the responsible party an opportunity to cease distribution and recall the food itself.
  2. If the company does not, the agency can order it to stop distributing the product. The FDA may narrow that order to certain geographic areas or markets when a narrower order would not compromise public health.
  3. The company is offered an informal hearing, held as soon as possible and not later than 2 days after the order is issued. The hearing deals with what the order requires and with the company’s reasons the food should not be recalled.
  4. After that, the agency can order the recall or vacate its order.

A company under a recall order has to notify the businesses holding the food. When product sits with a warehouse-based third party logistics provider that cannot tell which items are covered, the notice must contain enough information for the warehouse to identify them.

Who signs a recall order?

Only the FDA Commissioner can order a recall or vacate a recall order under this section. The statute says that authority cannot be delegated to any other officer or employee, so a field office or an inspector cannot issue one.

The department also has to set up an incident command operation, or something similar, that is working not later than 24 hours after a mandatory recall begins. The same requirement applies to any recall of food that will cause serious harm or death to humans or animals, and the department may run several of these operations when recalls or outbreaks overlap.

Why are most pet food recalls still voluntary?

Voluntary recalls remain the normal route because the law requires the FDA to offer that option before it issues any order. The section also says nothing in it changes the agency’s authority to request a voluntary recall or take part in one. A company that agrees at the first step never receives an order.

“Voluntary” on a notice therefore describes who started the recall. The product has still been pulled for a stated reason, and owners should treat it the same way as an ordered recall. The FDA also publishes advisories that are separate from recalls, such as its advisory about Salmonella in Darwin’s cat food.

Where did the Food Safety Modernization Act come from?

President Barack Obama signed the act, known as FSMA, after a decade of widely reported foodborne illness outbreaks. According to Wikipedia’s article on the FDA Food Safety Modernization Act, it is considered the first major federal food safety law since 1938, and the FDA had sought mandatory recall authority for many years before getting it. The Senate passed the bill in November 2010 by a vote of 73 to 25.

An earlier law had given the agency a related tool. The Bioterrorism Act of 2002 let the FDA detain food when credible evidence showed a threat of serious harm or death to humans or animals. FSMA lowered that bar to a “reason to believe” the food is adulterated or misbranded, and it shifted the agency’s work toward preventing contamination before products ship.

What should owners do when a pet food is recalled?

Stop feeding the product and compare the brand, size, lot number and best-by date on your bag or can with the notice. Our guide on how to check pet food recalls and what to do next walks through refunds, disposal and cleaning bowls. The lot code and date are printed on the package, and knowing how to read a pet food label makes them faster to find.

Call your veterinarian if your pet has eaten a recalled food and shows any of the signs listed in the notice. Raw products come up often in contamination notices, and our article on the risks of raw food diets for dogs explains what the FDA says about them.

Quick answers

Does the FDA’s mandatory recall power cover pet treats?

Yes. The section applies to articles of food other than infant formula and names harm to animals, and federal law counts pet food and treats as food.

Can a company fight a recall order?

It can argue its case at an informal hearing, which must take place not later than 2 days after the order is issued. The Commissioner then decides whether to order the recall or vacate the order.

Is a voluntary recall less serious than a mandatory one?

No such ranking appears in the law. The word says who initiated the recall, and the first step of the process always gives the company the chance to act on its own.

Does this power apply to infant formula or alcohol?

Infant formula is excluded from this section. For alcohol beverages, the FDA has to give the Alcohol and Tobacco Tax and Trade Bureau a reasonable opportunity to act under its own authority first.

Checked against official sources in November 2026. Hours, prices and rules change: confirm on the official page before you go or apply.